Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - 18

LEGISLATION
no guarantee that what you construct will be
compliant with the law. "
" What they're
doing has no
impact on
food safety,
so what
benefit does
California
actually
receive from
this? "
- MICHAEL FORMICA
And as time passes, construction costs
continue to rise, noted Christine McCracken,
senior analyst-Animal Protein at Rabobank.
" So, you've got lumber up, steel is up, PVC
is up - everything is higher, " she said, " and
in some cases, you can't even get equipment.
There are some real constraints in terms of the
costs of that transition going through the roof. "
Another consideration is Question 3, which
Massachusetts voters passed in 2016. The law
bars producers from confining laying hens,
breeding sows and veal calves in spaces that
prevent them from lying down, standing up,
fully extending their limbs or turning around
freely. The law also prohibits the sale of meat
from animals raised in non-compliant housing.
Formica, who submitted comments on the
law to the Massachusetts Attorney General's
Office, said state lawmakers also have
rulemaking under way, similar to California
- and like California lawmakers they are
behind schedule.
McCracken said she found it surprising that
producers weren't given a longer window in
which to convert their operations. But then no
one anticipated a global pandemic.
" I think officials in California have a lot
on their plate, " she said. " But it doesn't help
the fact the industry is going to be held to this
standard and unless we have some visibility, I
don't see much happening in terms of making
that transition. "
EXPLORING OPTIONS
The NPPC and the American Farm Bureau
Federation (AFBF) challenged Prop 12 in
December 2019, but a federal judge dismissed
that case in April. The groups filed an appeal in
the US Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit
in September. But in late July, a three-judge
panel affirmed the lower court's dismissal
of the action which argued that Proposition
12 violated the dormant Commerce Clause
which bars states from passing legislation that
discriminates against or burdens interstate
commerce.
" Even though the Council has plausibly
alleged that Proposition 12 will have dramatic
upstream effects and require pervasive
changes to the pork production industry
nationwide, it has not stated a violation of
18 MEAT+POULTRY | 09.21 | www.meatpoultry.com
the dormant Commerce Clause under our
existing precedent. "
Formica said California has very little pork
production, so all of the burden of complying
with Proposition 12 lies with out-of-state
pork producers.
" What would the benefit to California be? "
he asked. " What they're doing has no impact
on food safety, so what benefit does California
actually receive from this?
" If you look at the (proposed) regulations
that California came out with, in their
economic impact statement, they lay it out
pretty clearly - the only benefits of California
implementing Prop 12 are the voters who voted
for it know California is going to implement
it, and then non-consumers of these products
i.e., vegans, will feel better knowing that meat
eaters will have a difficult time finding the
meat that they want to eat and will have to pay
more money for it. That's not really a legitimate
state interest. "
The 9th Circuit ruling came one month
after the US Supreme Court denied, without
comment, a petition filed by the North
American Meat Institute (NAMI) asking the
court to review an appeal challenging the
constitutionality of Proposition 12.
" Prop 12 hurts the family on a budget by
causing higher prices for pork, veal and eggs,
and unfairly punishes livestock producers
outside of California by forcing them to spend
millions just to access California markets, "
said Julie Anna Potts, NAMI president and
chief executive officer. " If this unconstitutional
law is allowed to stand, California will dictate
farming practices across the nation. "
Formica said the NPPC will continue
evaluating what the next steps are going to be
in the case. One of the appellate judges called
the dormant Commerce Clause in the 9th
Circuit a " dead letter, " meaning the law still
exists but has lost its authority, and lawmakers
have not abolished or updated it.
" They could have overturned that as a
three-judge panel, but as conservative judges
they are inherently reluctant to overturn
precedent or to make new law, " Formica said.
" So, the next step would be to have an en
banc appeal to the 9th Circuit where all the
judges of the 9th Circuit come together and
consider the case; then they could overturn
this precedent, " Formica explained. " Or we go
http://www.meatpoultry.com

Meat+Poultry - September 2021

Table of Contents for the Digital Edition of Meat+Poultry - September 2021

Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - Intro
Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - VDG-1
Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - VDG-2
Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - 1
Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - 2
Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - 3
Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - 4
Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - 5
Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - 6
Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - 7
Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - 8
Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - 9
Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - 10
Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - 11
Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - 12
Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - 13
Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - 14
Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - 15
Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - 16
Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - 17
Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - 18
Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - 19
Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - 20
Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - 21
Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - 22
Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - 23
Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - 24
Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - 25
Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - 26
Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - 27
Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - 28
Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - 29
Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - 30
Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - 31
Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - 32
Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - 33
Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - 34
Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - 35
Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - 36
Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - 37
Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - 38
Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - 39
Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - 40
Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - 41
Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - 42
Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - 43
Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - 44
Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - 45
Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - 46
Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - 47
Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - 48
Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - 49
Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - 50
Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - 51
Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - 52
Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - 53
Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - 54
Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - 55
Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - 56
Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - 57
Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - 58
Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - 59
Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - 60
Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - 61
Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - 62
Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - 63
Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - 64
Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - 65
Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - 66
Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - 67
Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - 68
Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - 69
Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - 70
Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - 71
Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - 72
Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - 73
Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - 74
Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - 75
Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - 76
Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - 77
Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - 78
Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - 79
Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - 80
Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - 81
Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - 82
Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - 83
Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - 84
Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - 85
Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - 86
Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - 87
Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - 88
Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - 89
Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - 90
Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - 91
Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - 92
Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - 93
Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - 94
Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - 95
Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - 96
Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - 97
Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - 98
Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - 99
Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - 100
Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - 101
Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - 102
Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - 103
Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - 104
Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - PE-1
Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - PE-2
Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - PE-3
Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - PE-4
Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - PE-5
Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - PE-6
Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - PE-7
Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - PE-8
Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - PE-9
Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - PE-10
Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - PE-11
Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - PE-12
Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - PE-13
Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - PE-14
Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - PE-15
Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - PE-16
Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - PE-17
Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - PE-18
Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - PE-19
Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - PE-20
Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - PE-21
Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - PE-22
Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - PE-23
Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - PE-24
Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - PE-25
Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - PE-26
Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - PE-27
Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - PE-28
Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - Marel-1
Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - Marel-2
Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - Marel-3
Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - Marel-4
Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - Marel-5
Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - Marel-6
Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - Marel-7
Meat+Poultry - September 2021 - Marel-8
https://digital.meatpoultry.com/sosland/mp/meatpoultry-september-2021
https://digital.meatpoultry.com/sosland/mp/meatpoultry-august-2021
https://digital.meatpoultry.com/sosland/mp/meatpoultry-july-2021
https://digital.meatpoultry.com/sosland/mp/meatpoultry-june-2021
https://digital.meatpoultry.com/sosland/mp/meatpoultry-may-2021
https://digital.meatpoultry.com/sosland/mp/special-supplement-meat-alternatives-may-2021
https://digital.meatpoultry.com/sosland/mp/meatpoultry-april-2021
https://digital.meatpoultry.com/sosland/mp/meatpoultry-march-2021
https://digital.meatpoultry.com/sosland/mp/2021_02_01
https://digital.meatpoultry.com/sosland/mp/2021_01_01
https://digital.meatpoultry.com/sosland/mp/2020_12_01
https://digital.meatpoultry.com/sosland/mp/2020_11_01
https://digital.meatpoultry.com/sosland/mp/2020_10_01
https://digital.meatpoultry.com/sosland/mp/2020_09_01
https://digital.meatpoultry.com/sosland/mp/2020_08_01
https://digital.meatpoultry.com/sosland/mp/2020_07_01
https://digital.meatpoultry.com/sosland/mp/2020_06_01
https://digital.meatpoultry.com/sosland/mp/2020_05_01
https://digital.meatpoultry.com/sosland/mp/2020_04_01
https://digital.meatpoultry.com/sosland/mp/2020_03_01
https://digital.meatpoultry.com/sosland/mp/2020_02_01
https://digital.meatpoultry.com/sosland/mp/2020_01_01
https://digital.meatpoultry.com/sosland/mp/2019_12_01
https://digital.meatpoultry.com/sosland/mp/2019_11_01
https://digital.meatpoultry.com/sosland/mp/2019_10_01
https://digital.meatpoultry.com/sosland/mp/2019_09_01
https://digital.meatpoultry.com/sosland/mp/2019_08_01
https://digital.meatpoultry.com/sosland/mp/2019_07_11
https://digital.meatpoultry.com/sosland/mp/2019_06_01
https://digital.meatpoultry.com/sosland/mp/2019_05_01
https://digital.meatpoultry.com/sosland/mp/2019_04_01
https://digital.meatpoultry.com/sosland/mp/2019_03_01
https://digital.meatpoultry.com/sosland/mp/2019_02_01
https://digital.meatpoultry.com/sosland/mp/2019_01_01
http://digital.meatpoultry.com/sosland/mp/2018_12_01
http://digital.meatpoultry.com/sosland/mp/2018_11_01
http://digital.meatpoultry.com/sosland/mp/2018_10_01
http://digital.meatpoultry.com/sosland/mp/2018_09_01
http://digital.meatpoultry.com/sosland/mp/2018_08_01
http://digital.meatpoultry.com/sosland/mp/2018_07_01
http://digital.meatpoultry.com/sosland/mp/2018_06_01
http://digital.meatpoultry.com/sosland/mp/2018_05_01
http://digital.meatpoultry.com/sosland/mp/2018_04_01
http://digital.meatpoultry.com/sosland/mp/2018_03_01
https://www.nxtbook.com/sosland/mp/2018_02_01
https://www.nxtbook.com/sosland/mp/2018_01_01
https://www.nxtbook.com/sosland/mp/2017_12_01
https://www.nxtbook.com/sosland/mp/2017_11_01
https://www.nxtbook.com/sosland/mp/2017_10_01
https://www.nxtbook.com/sosland/mp/2017_09_01
https://www.nxtbook.com/sosland/mp/2017_08_01
https://www.nxtbook.com/sosland/mp/2017_07_01
https://www.nxtbook.com/sosland/mp/2017_06_01
https://www.nxtbook.com/sosland/mp/2017_05_01
https://www.nxtbook.com/sosland/mp/2017_04_01
https://www.nxtbook.com/sosland/mp/2017_03_01
https://www.nxtbook.com/sosland/mp/2017_02_01
https://www.nxtbook.com/sosland/mp/2017_01_01
https://www.nxtbook.com/sosland/mp/2016_12_01
https://www.nxtbook.com/sosland/mp/2016_11_01
https://www.nxtbook.com/sosland/mp/2016_10_01
https://www.nxtbook.com/sosland/mp/2016_09_01
https://www.nxtbook.com/sosland/mp/2016_08_01
https://www.nxtbook.com/sosland/mp/2016_07_01
https://www.nxtbook.com/sosland/mp/2016_06_01
https://www.nxtbook.com/sosland/mp/2016_05_01
https://www.nxtbook.com/sosland/mp/2016_04_01
https://www.nxtbook.com/sosland/mp/2016_03_01
https://www.nxtbook.com/sosland/mp/2016_02_01
https://www.nxtbook.com/sosland/mp/2016_01_01
https://www.nxtbook.com/sosland/mp/2015_12_01
https://www.nxtbook.com/sosland/mp/2015_11_01
https://www.nxtbook.com/sosland/mp/2015_10_01
https://www.nxtbook.com/sosland/mp/2015_09_01
https://www.nxtbook.com/sosland/mp/2015_08_01
https://www.nxtbook.com/sosland/mp/2015_07_01
https://www.nxtbook.com/sosland/mp/2015_06_01
https://www.nxtbook.com/sosland/mp/2015_05_01
https://www.nxtbook.com/sosland/mp/2015_04_01
https://www.nxtbook.com/sosland/mp/2015_03_01
https://www.nxtbook.com/sosland/mp/2015_02_01
https://www.nxtbook.com/sosland/mp/2015_01_01_mp
https://www.nxtbook.com/sosland/mp/2014_12_01
https://www.nxtbook.com/sosland/mp/2014_11_01
https://www.nxtbook.com/sosland/mp/2014_10_01
https://www.nxtbook.com/sosland/mp/2014_09_01
https://www.nxtbook.com/sosland/mp/2014_08_01
https://www.nxtbook.com/sosland/mp/2014_07_01
https://www.nxtbook.com/sosland/mp/2014_06_01
https://www.nxtbook.com/sosland/mp/2014_05_01
https://www.nxtbook.com/sosland/mp/2014_04_01
https://www.nxtbook.com/sosland/mp/2014_03_01
https://www.nxtbook.com/sosland/mp/2014_02_01
https://www.nxtbook.com/sosland/mp/2014_01_01
https://www.nxtbook.com/sosland/mp/2013_12_01
https://www.nxtbook.com/sosland/mp/2013_11_01
https://www.nxtbook.com/sosland/mp/2013_10_01
https://www.nxtbook.com/sosland/mp/2013_09_01
https://www.nxtbook.com/sosland/mp/2013_08_01
https://www.nxtbook.com/sosland/mp/2013_07_01
https://www.nxtbook.com/sosland/mp/2013_06_01
https://www.nxtbook.com/sosland/mp/2013_05_01
https://www.nxtbook.com/sosland/mp/2013_04_01
https://www.nxtbook.com/sosland/mp/2013_03_01
https://www.nxtbook.com/sosland/mp/2013_02_01
https://www.nxtbook.com/sosland/mp/2013_01_01
https://www.nxtbook.com/sosland/mp/2012_12_01
https://www.nxtbook.com/sosland/mp/2012_11_01
https://www.nxtbook.com/sosland/mp/2012_10_01
https://www.nxtbook.com/sosland/mp/2012_09_01
https://www.nxtbook.com/sosland/mp/2012_08_01
https://www.nxtbook.com/sosland/mp/2012_07_01
https://www.nxtbook.com/sosland/mp/2012_06_01
https://www.nxtbook.com/sosland/mp/2012_05_01
https://www.nxtbook.com/sosland/mp/2012_04_01
https://www.nxtbook.com/sosland/mp/2012_03_01
https://www.nxtbook.com/sosland/mp/2012_02_01
https://www.nxtbook.com/sosland/mp/2012_01_01
https://www.nxtbook.com/sosland/mp/2011_12_01
https://www.nxtbook.com/sosland/mp/2011_11_01
https://www.nxtbook.com/sosland/mp/2011_10_01
https://www.nxtbook.com/sosland/mp/2011_09_01
https://www.nxtbook.com/sosland/mp/2011_08_01
https://www.nxtbook.com/sosland/mp/2011_07_01
https://www.nxtbook.com/sosland/mp/2011_06_01
https://www.nxtbook.com/sosland/mp/2011_05_01
https://www.nxtbook.com/sosland/mp/2011_04_01
https://www.nxtbook.com/sosland/mp/2011_03_01
https://www.nxtbook.com/sosland/mp/2011_02_01
https://www.nxtbook.com/sosland/mp/2011_01_01
https://www.nxtbook.com/sosland/mp/2010_12_01
https://www.nxtbook.com/sosland/mp/2010_11_01
https://www.nxtbook.com/sosland/mp/2010_10_01
https://www.nxtbook.com/sosland/mp/2010_09_01
http://digital.meatpoultry.com/sosland/mp/2010_08_01
http://digital.meatpoultry.com/sosland/mp/2010_07_01
http://digital.meatpoultry.com/sosland/mp/2010_06_01
http://digital.meatpoultry.com/sosland/mp/2010_05_01
http://digital.meatpoultry.com/sosland/mp/2010_04_01
http://digital.meatpoultry.com/sosland/mp/2010_03_01
http://digital.meatpoultry.com/sosland/mp/2010_02_01
http://digital.meatpoultry.com/sosland/mp/2010_01_01
http://digital.meatpoultry.com/sosland/mp/2009_12_01
http://digital.meatpoultry.com/sosland/mp/2009_11_01
http://digital.meatpoultry.com/sosland/mp/2009_10_01
http://digital.meatpoultry.com/sosland/mp/2009_09_01
http://digital.meatpoultry.com/sosland/mp/2009_08_01
http://digital.meatpoultry.com/sosland/mp/2009_07_01
http://digital.meatpoultry.com/sosland/mp/2009_06_01
http://digital.meatpoultry.com/sosland/mp/2009_05_01
http://digital.meatpoultry.com/sosland/mp/2009_04_01
http://digital.meatpoultry.com/sosland/mp/2009_03_01
http://digital.meatpoultry.com/sosland/mp/2009_02_01
http://digital.meatpoultry.com/sosland/mp/2009_01_01
http://digital.meatpoultry.com/sosland/mp/2008_12_01
http://digital.meatpoultry.com/sosland/mp/2008_11_01
http://digital.meatpoultry.com/sosland/mp/2008_10_01
http://digital.meatpoultry.com/sosland/mp/2008_09_01
http://digital.meatpoultry.com/sosland/mp/2008_08_01
http://digital.meatpoultry.com/sosland/mp/2008_07_01
http://digital.meatpoultry.com/sosland/mp/2008_06_01
http://digital.meatpoultry.com/sosland/mp/2008_05_01
http://digital.meatpoultry.com/sosland/mp/2008_04_01
http://digital.meatpoultry.com/sosland/mp/2008_03_01
http://digital.meatpoultry.com/sosland/mp/2008_02_01
http://digital.meatpoultry.com/sosland/mp/2008_01_01
http://digital.meatpoultry.com/sosland/mp/2007_12_01
http://digital.meatpoultry.com/sosland/mp/2007_11_01
http://digital.meatpoultry.com/sosland/mp/2007_10_01
http://digital.meatpoultry.com/sosland/mp/2007_09_01
http://digital.meatpoultry.com/sosland/mp/2007_08_01
http://digital.meatpoultry.com/sosland/mp/2007_07_01
http://digital.meatpoultry.com/sosland/mp/2007_06_01
http://digital.meatpoultry.com/sosland/mp/2007_05_01
http://digital.meatpoultry.com/sosland/mp/2007_04_01
http://digital.meatpoultry.com/sosland/mp/2007_03_01
http://digital.meatpoultry.com/sosland/mp/2007_02_01
http://digital.meatpoultry.com/sosland/mp/2007_01_01
http://digital.meatpoultry.com/sosland/mp/2006_12_01
http://digital.meatpoultry.com/sosland/mp/2006_11_01
http://digital.meatpoultry.com/sosland/mp/2006_10_01
http://digital.meatpoultry.com/sosland/mp/2006_09_01
http://digital.meatpoultry.com/sosland/mp/2006_08_01
http://digital.meatpoultry.com/sosland/mp/2006_07_01
http://digital.meatpoultry.com/sosland/mp/2006_06_01
http://digital.meatpoultry.com/sosland/mp/2006_05_01
http://digital.meatpoultry.com/sosland/mp/2006_04_01
http://digital.meatpoultry.com/sosland/mp/2006_03_01
http://digital.meatpoultry.com/sosland/mp/2006_02_01
http://digital.meatpoultry.com/sosland/mp/2006_01_01
http://digital.meatpoultry.com/sosland/mp/2005_12_01
http://digital.meatpoultry.com/sosland/mp/2005_11_01
http://digital.meatpoultry.com/sosland/mp/2005_10_01
http://digital.meatpoultry.com/sosland/mp/2005_09_01
http://digital.meatpoultry.com/sosland/mp/2005_08_01
http://digital.meatpoultry.com/sosland/mp/2005_07_01
http://digital.meatpoultry.com/sosland/mp/2005_06_01
http://digital.meatpoultry.com/sosland/mp/2005_05_01
http://digital.meatpoultry.com/sosland/mp/2005_04_01
http://digital.meatpoultry.com/sosland/mp/2005_03_01
http://digital.meatpoultry.com/sosland/mp/2005_02_01
http://digital.meatpoultry.com/sosland/mp/2005_01_01
http://digital.meatpoultry.com/sosland/mp/2004_12_01
http://digital.meatpoultry.com/sosland/mp/2004_11_01
http://digital.meatpoultry.com/sosland/mp/2004_10_01
http://digital.meatpoultry.com/sosland/mp/2004_09_01
http://digital.meatpoultry.com/sosland/mp/2004_08_01
http://digital.meatpoultry.com/sosland/mp/2004_07_01
http://digital.meatpoultry.com/sosland/mp/2004_06_01
http://digital.meatpoultry.com/sosland/mp/2004_05_01
http://digital.meatpoultry.com/sosland/mp/2004_04_01
http://digital.meatpoultry.com/sosland/mp/2004_03_01
http://digital.meatpoultry.com/sosland/mp/2004_02_01
http://digital.meatpoultry.com/sosland/mp/2004_01_01
http://digital.meatpoultry.com/sosland/mp/2003_12_01
http://digital.meatpoultry.com/sosland/mp/2003_10_01
https://www.nxtbookmedia.com